Gotham Steel 1359 Baking Pan Review – Nonstick, Durable, and Dishwasher Safe

Description

Gotham Steel Ultra Nonstick Rectangular Baking Pan Review – My Honest Take

I recently got my hands on the Gotham Steel Ultra Nonstick Rectangular Baking Pan (Item Model Number: 1359), and let me tell you, this pan has been a game-changer in my kitchen. As someone who bakes obsessively (seriously, my friends “lovingly” call me the Cake Queen), I have gone through more pans than I care to admit. This one, though? It’s built differently. Let me walk you through my experience while also throwing in a few laughs and lessons learned.

My First Bake: A Sticky Situation Avoided

The first thing I made with this 9″x13″ baking pan was a gooey batch of brownies. Typically, I have to grease my pans like my life depends on it. But with this pan? Not a drop of oil or butter was needed. The ultra-nonstick ceramic coating, which is apparently triple-layered, worked like magic. Those brownies slid out like they were on a conveyor belt. I didn’t believe it at first, so I made another batch the next day. Same result. My husband was thrilled—more brownies for him, less scrubbing for me.

Features That Stood Out

This rectangular baking pan has a lot going for it. It’s oven-safe up to 500°F, which means it can handle everything from cakes to casseroles. The no-warp technology ensures that the pan stays perfectly flat, even after multiple uses. I’ve had pans in the past that looked like they were auditioning for a role as a U-shape, but this one? Sturdy as they come.

The metal utensil-safe claim had me raising an eyebrow, though. Out of curiosity (and let’s be honest, a little skepticism), I used a metal spatula. After a few uses, I noticed very slight scratches—not enough to ruin the pan, but enough to make me switch to silicone utensils. So, while it’s technically safe, I’d still recommend being cautious.

My Mom’s Lasagna Test

I lent the pan to my mom for her famous lasagna. It passed her test with flying colors. She loved how deep the pan was, which allowed for a generous amount of sauce and layers. Plus, the even-heating technology meant there were no cold spots, which is a big deal. Nobody likes a half-cooked lasagna.

Comparing It to the Competition

I’ve tried a lot of bakeware brands, from Pyrex to Wilton. Here’s how the Gotham Steel Baking Pan stacks up:

• Wilton pans: Great for precision baking but lack the nonstick magic of Gotham Steel.
• Pyrex glass pans: Durable but heavy, and they need greasing.
• Gotham Steel: Lightweight, genuinely nonstick, and dishwasher-safe, making it a more convenient option.

The nonstick coating is what sets Gotham Steel apart. However, Pyrex might have a slight edge in heat retention. So, it really depends on what you’re looking for.

Is It Worth the Money?

While I won’t put an exact price tag here, I can confidently say that this pan is a solid investment. It’s durable, versatile, and saves you time on cleanup. Yes, there are cheaper pans out there, but they don’t offer the combination of nonstick performance and durability that this one does.

Some Quirks to Keep in Mind

Of course, no product is perfect. While the dishwasher-safe feature is convenient, I’ve found that handwashing preserves the nonstick coating better. Also, the brown color doesn’t really match my kitchen aesthetic, but hey, that’s a minor gripe.

Overall, the Gotham Steel Ultra Nonstick Rectangular Baking Pan is a star in my kitchen. Whether I’m baking cakes for birthdays or roasting veggies for dinner, this pan delivers.

Pros

• Ultra Nonstick Performance: Foods genuinely slide off the surface without any greasing or prep.
• Oven-Safe Up to 500°F: Handles a wide range of recipes without warping or damage.
• Lightweight Yet Sturdy: Easy to handle, even when loaded with heavy casseroles.
• Dishwasher-Safe: Cleanup is a breeze, although handwashing is recommended for longevity.
• Versatile Use: Ideal for baking cakes, brownies, and even roasting veggies.

Cons

• Metal Utensil Use May Cause Scratches: Despite claims, using metal utensils left light marks after repeated use.
• Nonstick Coating Durability Over Time: A few reviewers noted that the coating may peel with heavy use over years.
• Limited Design Aesthetic: The brown finish may not appeal to everyone’s kitchen style.
• Handwashing Recommended for Best Results: While dishwasher-safe, frequent dishwasher use might reduce the pan’s lifespan.

What Comes with the Product

• 1 Gotham Steel Ultra Nonstick Rectangular Baking Pan (9″x13″)
  (Note: No additional accessories are included.)

How to Use Guide

1. Preheat Oven: Make sure the oven is set to the desired temperature (up to 500°F).
2. Prepare Ingredients: Mix and prep whatever you’re baking or roasting.
3. No Grease Needed: Skip the butter or oil. The ultra nonstick coating handles it all.
4. Place Pan in Oven: Carefully slide it onto the rack.
5. Monitor Cooking Time: Use a timer to avoid overcooking.
6. Cool Down: Let the pan cool before attempting to remove food.
7. Clean Gently: Handwash or place in the dishwasher for easy cleanup.

Warranty & Support Information

The Gotham Steel Ultra Nonstick Rectangular Baking Pan comes with a limited manufacturer’s warranty, covering defects in materials or workmanship. Buyers can contact E Mishan & Sons for warranty claims. For support, it’s recommended to have the UPC code (724456945844) and purchase details handy. This ensures a smoother process when reaching out to customer service.

Additional information