Gotham Steel 1389 Nonstick Cookie Sheet Review – Durable and Dishwasher Safe

Description

Gotham Steel Non Stick Baking Sheet Review – Real Thoughts After Testing This Cookie Sheet

My baking adventures recently led me to test the Gotham Steel Non Stick Baking Sheet, model 1389, and I must say, it’s a unique addition to my kitchen arsenal. As someone who loves baking cookies, roasting veggies, and occasionally testing Pinterest recipes that don’t quite work out, I was curious to see if this baking sheet could live up to the hype.

Let me start with the “non-stick” promise because, honestly, that’s a bold claim. I decided to bake my go-to chocolate chip cookies on this sheet. To my surprise (and slight disbelief), the cookies practically glided off the tray—no parchment paper, no oil, no butter. It was as if the cookies had their own built-in escape plan. This was a huge win for me because I despise scrubbing sheets post-baking. However, the real test came when I baked parmesan-crusted chicken. The cheese melted, bubbled, and browned, but cleaning it afterward? A quick wipe with a sponge, and it was spotless!

The Good, The Great, and The “Did That Just Happen?”

The ceramic non-stick coating is genuinely impressive. Gotham Steel advertises that this baking sheet is “triple coated” for durability, and it shows. Even sticky, sugary spills didn’t cling to the surface. My daughter spilled caramel on it (don’t ask), and I was mentally preparing for an hour-long scrub session. Instead, it wiped clean in seconds. Score!

I also love that this sheet is free from PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS. It’s reassuring to know I’m baking on something that isn’t leaching questionable chemicals into my food. Plus, it’s dishwasher safe, though I rarely needed the dishwasher because it’s just so easy to clean.

But here’s the kicker: this thing doesn’t warp. My previous baking sheets have done weird gymnastics in the oven at high temps—bending, popping, and making me question their integrity. The 0.8mm thick aluminum gauge on this sheet ensures it heats evenly, without the dreaded warping. I baked at 475°F, and it held its shape like a champ. The edges are rolled for extra sturdiness, which probably helps.

Comparing Competitors

I’ve used Wilton and Nordic Ware sheets before, and while they’re decent, they’ve had their issues. Wilton pans tend to develop sticky spots after a while, and Nordic Ware sheets, while durable, don’t have the same effortless non-stick capabilities. Gotham Steel beats them both in non-stick performance and ease of cleaning, though Nordic Ware might slightly edge it out in terms of overall durability.

What’s Not Perfect?

I did notice that the ceramic coating is delicate. While it’s labeled as metal utensil safe, I wouldn’t push my luck. A gentle silicone spatula or wooden spoon is your best friend here. Also, don’t go over the 500°F heat limit—one user review mentioned that the non-stick properties can degrade if you exceed this.

Lastly, while the tray is fantastic for cookies, pizzas, and roasted veggies, it’s not the best for broiling. The dark coating means food browns quickly, which isn’t ideal if you’re aiming for that slow, even caramelization.

Cost vs. Value

It’s priced somewhere in the middle of the baking sheet spectrum—not the cheapest, not the most expensive. For the features it offers, like the ceramic non-stick coating and even heat distribution, I’d say it’s worth every penny. Sure, you could spend less, but you’d probably end up replacing a cheaper sheet sooner.

Features in Action

• Dimensions: At 17.7” x 12.7”, this is a full-size baking sheet, perfect for large batches. But beware—it’s not ideal for small ovens.
• Heat Resistance: Safe up to 500°F, but as mentioned earlier, don’t push it.
• Metal Utensil Safe: This is a nice feature, but I’d still recommend silicone or plastic tools for longevity.
• Dishwasher Safe: After a heavy cooking session, this is a lifesaver.

Would I recommend it? Absolutely, though with a few caveats. If you’re careful about maintaining the ceramic coating and not exceeding the heat limit, this baking sheet might just become your new best friend in the kitchen.

Pros

• Effortless Non-Stick Coating: Truly non-stick without the need for butter, oil, or parchment paper.
• Easy Cleanup: A quick sponge wipe is often enough, or toss it into the dishwasher.
• Warp-Free Design: The rolled edges and thick construction make it incredibly durable, even at high temperatures.
• Chemical-Free: PTFE, PFOA, and PFOS-free for safe cooking.
• Even Heat Distribution: Great for evenly baked cookies and perfectly roasted vegetables.

Cons

• Heat Limitations: Going above 500°F can compromise the non-stick coating.
• Delicate Coating: Although it claims to be metal utensil safe, scratches can happen if you’re not careful.
• Not Ideal for Broiling: Food browns too quickly on the dark surface at high heat.
• Size: The full-size dimensions may not fit smaller ovens.

What Comes with the Product

• One 17.7” x 12.7” Gotham Steel Non Stick Baking Sheet.

How to Use Guide

1. Preheat Your Oven: Ensure the temperature doesn’t exceed 500°F.
2. No Prep Necessary: Skip the parchment paper or greasing. The non-stick coating handles it all.
3. Place Food or Dough: Lay your cookies, veggies, or meat directly on the sheet.
4. Bake Away: Let your food cook evenly, thanks to the warp-free design.
5. Cool Down: Allow the sheet to cool before cleaning.
6. Clean Gently: Use a soft sponge with warm water or place it in the dishwasher.
7. Store Properly: Avoid stacking with heavy pans to prevent scratches.

Warranty & Support Information

Gotham Steel offers a limited lifetime warranty on their products, which is a great bonus. This warranty covers defects in materials and workmanship, but it doesn’t cover damage from improper use (like overheating or using metal utensils). For support, you can contact the manufacturer directly through their website or customer service line. Keep your proof of purchase handy in case you need assistance or wish to claim the warranty.

Additional information